Law, Ethics, & News Literacy

The “Vermont Statutes Title 16. Education, § 180, Student Rights—Freedom of Expression” law allows for substantial freedom for student journalists. Therefore, students can not be censored or disciplined for journalistic endeavors that do not cause obvious harm to others in the community.


Beyond the law, however, I have felt very supported and protected in my journalistic freedoms by the administration, faculty, and staff. Both faculty advisors have provided remarkable latitude in this work. Although, at various times, both advisors have asked to see the slugs (preview articles), they have not requested significant changes to content. We have been able to cover controversial topics without reprimand, such as questioning school policies and discussing national politics.

In fact, I have instead reached out for guidance on rare occasions when I have been unclear what is the best course of action to continue to respect student privacy and maintain journalistic integrity. On one such occasion, we had a medical incident at a community event. Some staff members wanted to cover the event fully, but others felt privacy should be maintained. The school principal and faculty advisor were immensely helpful in providing me with language to navigate the incident. As a product of working together, I feel there is trust and mutual respect in this endeavor.

Although The Hawks’ Nest’s staff has been very aware of the need to respect our community, I work hard in the editing process to ensure that language is respectively delivered and that there is nothing obscene or slanderous. In addition, I work to ensure quotes are properly attributed and appropriately sourced. On occasion, we have cited anonymous sources, with permission of the individual providing the quote. In a small community, we also have worked to ensure the appropriate pronoun is used in our coverage or have preferentially used names over pronouns when this information is not known. Any needed corrections are covered in the subsequent issue.

While obtaining photographic coverage of community events has required some resourcefulness, the effort does not end there. As some students have opted not to sign the school’s photo release waiver, I have needed to follow up with images that capture student faces in an identifiable way. Occasionally, I have blurred faces if I have been unable to get this information in a timely manner or have changed the page layout to accommodate this requirement. I have also followed up with each image to ensure that appropriate credit is obtained. Photo credits are listed under images and individuals are also credited in the masthead.

I am currently working to obtain course credit for future editors and staff writers for participation in The Hawks’ Nest. I am hopeful that this future curriculum can more thoroughly explore the legal and ethical responsibilities of student journalism.